Murder, She Baked: A Plum Pudding Mystery
2015 · 84 min · Director: Kristoffer Tabori, Kristoffer Tabori
Show plot summary (may contain spoilers)
It's one week before Christmas in the small, generally quiet town of Eden Lake, Minnesota. After not pursuing romance for most of her adult life, Hannah Swensen, owner/operator of Hannah's Cookie Jar, a bakery/café, is being wooed by two men, who know about the other in Hannah's life. Hannah likes both a lot, but has not even kissed either. While her mother, Delores Swensen, is pushing her into the arms of dentist Norman Rhodes as the person who will provide her with a stable, comfortable life, her sister, Andrea Todd, is pushing her into the arms of Andrea's deputy sheriff husband Bill Todd's colleague, police detective Mike Kingston, as the more exciting choice. What seems to be becoming a more chronic issue in Hannah's life is that she is the person who finds someone murdered in Eden Lake, this time the victim being one of her customers, Larry Jaeger, co-owner of the Crazy Elf Christmas tree lot with his fiancée, Courtney Miller, the two who got engaged after knowing each other for only six weeks. Larry's murder is only the second such in recent memory in the town, and the second such body Hannah has discovered. Hannah can't help but get involved in the investigation, either by accident or usually more on purpose, which irks both Norman and Mike as putting her life in danger. Mike is additionally bothered that her amateur sleuthing is interfering with his official investigation. At the top of the suspect list is Delores' friend, Nancy Schmidt who is better known in town as radio talk show host on issues of the lovelorn, Dr. Love. Nancy is not Larry's ex-wife as she had implied to Delores, but rather his wife - at least up until his murder - he who she claims not to have seen in ten years as he bilked her out of her money and disappeared without a trace until now. The further Hannah and Mike investigate, the further they find that Larry was generally not a nice person who had many enemies who had motive to want to see him dead. What Hannah may or may not be aware is that she is getting closer to the truth which truly does put her life in danger as the murderer would probably not hesitate to murder a second time if she gets too close to discovering the truth.
Your viewing check-in
Emotional fingerprint
Murder, She Baked: A Plum Pudding Mystery (2015) — Movie. Top emotional signals: Curiosity 30%, Humor 25%, Anticipation 20%. Source: AI estimate. Shares describe emotional signal, not percentages of people. Your experience may differ. How we measure
- Curiosity30%
- Humor25%
- Anticipation20%
- Love15%
- Satisfaction10%
AI estimate · no viewer votes yet
How we measure
AI estimate
Share of emotional signal, not the percentage of people or a probability of enjoyment.
Each viewer contributes one response, split equally across their selected emotions. When available, an automated estimate supplies a prior that is blended with those responses. Counts include distinct viewers, not automated estimates or archived anonymous votes. Fewer than 3 viewers is an early estimate; more responses do not guarantee certainty.
Why it feels this way
The strongest emotional signals are Curiosity, Humor, Anticipation. Genres: Romance, Mystery, Crime. AI estimate.
Is it worth watching?
Consider this title if you are looking for Curiosity, Humor and Anticipation. Its IMDb rating of 6.8/10 suggests a generally positive audience reception. For these leading emotions, its Feel Score is 68/100.
How did it make you feel?
Votes are saved to the fingerprint once you’re signed in.
Pick up to three · 0/3
Emotional journey
- Curiosity
- Tension
- Humor
Not enough subtitle evidence
No dominant emotion
Dominant emotion: Joy
Dominant emotion: Love
Dominant emotion: Tension
Dominant emotion: Curiosity
Dominant emotion: Humor
Dominant emotion
| % | Approximate minute | Dominant emotion | Overall intensity | Curiosity | Tension | Humor |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2.5 % | ≈ 2′ | Joy | 34 % | 13 % | 3 % | 23 % |
| 7.5 % | ≈ 6′ | Joy | 38 % | 16 % | 6 % | 30 % |
| 12.5 % | ≈ 11′ | Love | 43 % | 18 % | 8 % | 34 % |
| 17.5 % | ≈ 15′ | Love | 50 % | 26 % | 20 % | 26 % |
| 22.5 % | ≈ 19′ | Tension | 57 % | 42 % | 41 % | 17 % |
| 27.5 % | ≈ 23′ | Curiosity | 54 % | 49 % | 38 % | 20 % |
| 32.5 % | ≈ 27′ | Curiosity | 50 % | 49 % | 25 % | 27 % |
| 37.5 % | ≈ 32′ | Curiosity | 51 % | 51 % | 25 % | 27 % |
| 42.5 % | ≈ 36′ | Curiosity | 53 % | 53 % | 27 % | 20 % |
| 47.5 % | ≈ 40′ | Curiosity | 49 % | 44 % | 26 % | 20 % |
| 52.5 % | ≈ 44′ | Humor | 47 % | 31 % | 23 % | 34 % |
| 57.5 % | ≈ 48′ | Humor | 53 % | 37 % | 21 % | 41 % |
| 62.5 % | ≈ 53′ | Curiosity | 58 % | 52 % | 28 % | 30 % |
| 67.5 % | ≈ 57′ | Curiosity | 57 % | 50 % | 32 % | 27 % |
| 72.5 % | ≈ 61′ | Love | 52 % | 35 % | 22 % | 31 % |
| 77.5 % | ≈ 65′ | Love | 48 % | 35 % | 14 % | 27 % |
| 82.5 % | ≈ 69′ | Curiosity | 51 % | 44 % | 17 % | 30 % |
| 87.5 % | ≈ 74′ | Humor | 61 % | 51 % | 36 % | 39 % |
| 92.5 % | ≈ 78′ | Tension | 75 % | 55 % | 64 % | 29 % |
| 97.5 % | ≈ 82′ | Tension | 82 % | 52 % | 78 % | 15 % |
Oedipus
Rags to riches: The emotional tone rises from negative to positive.
Riches to rags: The emotional tone falls from positive to negative.
Man in a hole: The tone falls, then recovers.
Icarus: The tone rises, then falls.
Cinderella: The tone rises, falls, then rises again.
Oedipus: The tone falls, rises, then falls again.
AI reading of the film’s English subtitles (dialogue and sound cues) — not viewer votes. How we measure ↗
Kadri — your film companion
AIAsk anything about Murder, She Baked: A Plum Pudding Mystery. From the film’s own dialogue and FeelDB data, at your spoiler level.
Kadri
Hi, I’m Kadri. Ask me anything about Murder, She Baked: A Plum Pudding Mystery — I’ll stay inside your spoiler line.
Premise onlyAfterward Reveal viewer responses · may contain spoilers
Viewer responses about feelings after the title ended, separate from feelings while watching. No AI estimates.
0 responses so far
Feeling details appear after at least 3 viewers respond, to protect privacy.
Cast
Luanne
Earl
Courtney Miller
Lydia
Details
- Directed by
- Kristoffer Tabori, Kristoffer Tabori
- Written by
- Nancey Silvers, Joanne Fluke
- Type
- Movies
- Released
- 2015
- Runtime
- 84 min
- Country
- United States, Canada
- Ratings
- Feels mostly
- Curiosity
- Data updated
Where to watch
Subscription
Rent
Feels similar
More like this →Emotion overlap shows mood similarity, not a prediction of enjoyment.





